In June 2025, Knoxville-Knox County Planning approved a Taco Bell drive-through for the lot at 5902 Kingston Pike. The plan would have removed the small white chapel with the oversized bell tower that sits on the rise in Bearden. On Nov. 1, 2026, that chapel held a grand opening as Saint Clare Collective, a gift shop with its original church pews and bookshelves still inside.
Coming west on Kingston Pike from Sequoyah Hills, you'll find it just past the center of Bearden, next to Pelican's SnoBalls and near Sitar Indian Cuisine. Most reports on the opening call it a 19th-century chapel. The building is younger than that. The 1880s part of the property is the small cemetery behind it, and those graves shaped the demolition approval more than the chapel did.
A 1925 building on an 1880s site
Knoxville History Project corrected the date in 2024. Historian Jack Neely wrote that a church stood on the site by 1883 and its roots there went back a few years earlier. That first church fell out of use around 1921, and it was torn down after a couple of years of sitting empty.
The building on the lot today went up in spring 1925, built by what remained of the congregation. Neely quotes the April 19, 1925 Knoxville Journal:
"The framework was erected by volunteer labor, and was practically completed in one day. Worship was held in the church that night."
So the chapel isn't 140 years old. Neely still calls it Bearden's oldest non-residential building, a frame church that has watched the old Dixie Highway traffic, the Southern Railway passenger trains behind it and the shopping center across the street come and go. When it was built, Bearden's train station stood just around the corner on what is now Northshore Drive, near the trestle that still crosses the road.
The churchyard is older than the building. Neely counts about 35 graves, some dating to 1881, with Bearden family names like Gore, Craig, Knott and Roehl. Nearly all of them were buried behind the earlier church. One stone belongs to Julia Ann Lamons and names the New Market Train Wreck of Sept. 24, 1904, which Neely calls the deadliest peacetime disaster in East Tennessee history. A weathered military stone marks a Civil War soldier of the U.S. 6th Tennessee Infantry.
The site has a claim on a Tennessee institution as well. In 1892, Rev. Ashley S. Johnson used a sermon at this church to announce plans for a college. Afterward a parishioner, Union veteran William F. Crippen, handed him $100. That school is now Johnson University in Kimberlin Heights.
How the lot came close to becoming a drive-through
The chapel has had several lives. It was Bearden Christian Church, later a Korean Christian Church, and more recently a Brazilian jiu-jitsu studio. Before that, the congregation donated it to the Royal Chaplain Corps, a ministry for first responders. That group restored the hardwood floors and rehung the original bell in a new belfry.
Here is how the property changed hands and plans:
| Date | What happened at 5902 Kingston Pike |
|---|---|
| 2017 | Developer Tony Cappiello buys the property, planning to preserve the church and rent it out |
| 2018 | A few special events held after remodeling |
| 2024 | Chapel listed for sale on the condition that the buyer move it off the site |
| April 28, 2025 | Taco Bell of America files Planning case 6-E-25-SU |
| June 12, 2025 | Planning Commission approves the drive-through with conditions, 10 to 1 |
| Nov. 1, 2026 | Saint Clare Collective holds its grand opening inside the chapel |
The 2024 sale banner surprised Neely. It read "THIS 1885 CHAPEL FOR SALE / MUST RELOCATE TO YOUR PROPERTY / VENUE," and he wrote that he had never heard of a Knoxville developer selling a historic building on the condition that it be moved. He also noted that moving it would make it ineligible for the National Register of Historic Places, because a moved building counts as an artifact rather than a historic site.
The Taco Bell plan covered the full 0.94-acre site. The chapel, its annex and a former house were slated for demolition. The cemetery was to stay, fenced off.
The condition that put the graves first
The cemetery ran the approval. According to the Planning case record, before any site-disturbance permit could be issued, an archaeologist had to oversee grading and stripping to look for possible unmarked graves, and Planning had to review the results. Any graves found would get a 10-foot buffer. Planning's staff report describes the burial ground as active from the early 1880s through the 1920s.
So by the time of the June 2025 vote, the 1925 chapel was set for removal, and the 1880s graves behind it were the part of the lot the plan had to work around. Neely ended his 2024 piece on the same point: "But that old 1880s-1920s graveyard is still back there. I trust it's not part of the deal."
The chapel is still on its original site. As Knox News put it on Nov. 3, drivers won't be picking up a five-layer burrito there, "but they might be able to feed their souls."
What's inside now
Allie Fleming renovated the chapel with help from family and friends. They kept the original pews and bookshelves and use them as the shop's fixtures. Knox News reports that the shop is meant in part to fill a gap left by The Paraclete, the Catholic book and gift store that closed in 2024. The East Tennessee Catholic reported that The Paraclete closed on July 3 that year after 37 years. Its last home was 417 Erin Drive, next to the cathedral, and the growing parish needed the space for offices and ministry meeting rooms.
When Saint Clare Collective opened, Knox News listed both faith-based and everyday items:
- Books, crosses, rosaries, nativities, Advent wreaths and devotional candles
- Home décor, women's clothing and jewelry
- Vols items and toys
- Vintage pieces and work by local makers
The vintage items have their own section, Lantern & Lily, stocked with finds collected around East Tennessee, according to the shop's launch announcement on MoxCar. Fleming explained the shop's approach in a news release quoted by Knox News:
"We are proud of both our faith-based offerings and universal products, and we welcome people of all and any faiths and none whatsoever who may want to browse our diverse selection."
Why the timing matters this month
The shop opened at the start of the holiday gift season, and Advent wreaths, nativities and holiday ornaments were part of its opening stock. If you've been running gift errands up and down Kingston Pike, you can now make that stop at the building you've been driving past for years. KnoxTNToday's opening coverage places the shop next door to Pelican's SnoBalls. For hours and updates, check the shop's Instagram, @SaintClareCollective, or its Facebook page.
When you go, walk around back. The graves behind the chapel include some of the oldest in Bearden, among them Julia Ann Lamons's stone with its 1904 inscription and the worn marker of a Union soldier.
At 5902 Kingston Pike, the date on the sale banner was off by four decades, and the conditions in the 2025 approval were written around the graves rather than the building. If you're weighing an older property in Sequoyah Hills or along the Kingston Pike corridor, Ashley Wade can help you check what a house's history, its records and its construction actually say before you commit. Request your bespoke consultation.